Defense of another
Forty or fifty years ago, my friend Wendy dragged me to an abortion debate, an event populated mostly by women. The debate began in an orderly manner and then devolved into chaos. Simplifying for concision, the dialogue proceeded something like this:
Pro-abortion woman: "It's my body"
Pro-life woman: "It's not your body that dies in the abortion."
Pro-abortion woman: "It's my choice."
Pro-life woman: "You made your choice when you got pregnant!"
Pro-abortion woman: "It's my privacy."

Pro-life woman: "The same privacy as bank-robbers!"
Pro-abortion woman: "It's just a clump of cells."
Pro-life woman: "It's alive!"
Pro-abortion woman: "It's not a human person."
Pro-life woman: "It's the result of the fertilization of a human ovum by a human spermatozoon, so it is human."
Pro-abortion woman: "It may be human, but it's not a person until it's born."
Pro-life woman: "It is a fully formed human baby!"
That last pro-life retort is the weakest. Even Roe allowed abortion restrictions after viability and presumed that viability implied personhood. Hence the attention Joe Biden and Whoopi Goldberg gathered when they recently said the fetus is a child. Not that I consider either of them expert on the question, but it is an interesting development, isn't it?
Image: Baby by freepic.diller.
After all, the fetus is alive, and hence is either vegetable or animal; and if animal, is neither cat, nor dog, nor horse, nor anything else other than human. Since the fetus is the result of the fertilization of a human ovum by a human spermatozoon, it is surely a human life form.
If the fetus is a child, then it is a human person and has all the rights of any citizen. That would include life, liberty, property — the whole nine yards of American civil rights.
And that includes the right to self-defense.
So far as I am aware, the fetus has no means available to defend itself against the abortionist, but since many of the technological realities of today are beyond my imagination, I withhold judgment about what the future may hold for fetal defense mechanisms. But realize that if such fetal defense mechanisms somehow came into existence, the fetus would obviously be lawfully authorized to employ them against the abortionist!
Moreover, something else is clear: in a circumstance in which a person has a right to self-defense, it is a matter of black-letter law that this right of self-defense can be exercised by another person on behalf of the person with the right. This is called "defense of another." So it is that, if I see Person A malevolently trying to kill Person B, with Person B unable to defend himself, I can legally spring to Person B's defense. You should Google Duck Duck Go Qwant it. You'll get lots of hits.
And no, I am most definitely not advocating that pro-life people hunt down abortionists. Doing so is illegal, counterproductive, stupid, and immoral. This is simply a different way of looking at the issue and understanding why every pro-life person has a moral obligation to speak out and vote against abortion, especially when the matter comes to state legislatures. In our Brave New World, this is an interesting way to look at the issue, right?
FOLLOW US ON
Recent Articles
- Not in Kansas Any More
- Democrats Dying on the Most Desolate Hills
- If She’s an Astronaut … I’m a Jet Fighter Pilot
- Is the Jihadist Trojan Horse Winning?
- Who Has the Best American Autobiography?
- This Easter, Let Us Renew Our Faith
- Is it Time to Ignore the Judiciary?
- Higher Ed is Fighting Back!
- Easter: the Resurrection of Jesus Transformed the World Forever
- Trump’s vision for technological greatness
Blog Posts
- Hillary ‘the Russia Hoaxer’ Clinton wants to imprison people for ‘propaganda’
- Rep. Jamie Raskin threatens foreign leaders who cooperate with President Trump with repercussions, 'when we come back to power — and we will'
- Maybe we need more living versions of “Hillbilly Funerals”
- A female fencer's courage is partly rewarded
- Democrats' Cloward-Piven default
- A New Mexico judge resigned over allegations that he kept a Tren de Aragua member in his home
- The Pope’s death is leading to yet more anti-Israel and anti-Trump propaganda
- Ivy League college invites antisemitic rapper onto campus
- Pope Francis, RIP
- It’s not really about Abrego Garcia
- When Oregon became Bart Jason
- Post-election lawfare; legislating from the bench
- Oregon pushes trans track
- The Starliner: worse than we thought
- Professional sports leagues push gun control