A migration pact to disaster
For the past two years, U.N. bureaucrats have worked diligently, if quietly, on something called the "Global Compact for Safe, Orderly and Regular Migration." What has now become clear from its publication, and even more by analysis from Gatestone Institute's formidable Judith Bergman, is that, given the source, the "Compact" is little more than unalloyed leftist propaganda.
Migration, we are told in no uncertain terms, is "a source of prosperity, innovation and sustainable development in our globalized world," while the secretary general of the U.N., Antonio Guterres, chimes in that it is "a positive global phenomenon." No mention is made of the fact that uncontrolled migration of the kind permitted by Germany in 2015-2016 has proven to be a disaster, as even Chancellor Merkel and those supporting her admit. Similarly, after many years of unlimited immigration, Jewish synagogues and private businesses in France now have to be guarded by the military, and 63% of German Turks voted for Islamist dictator ErdoДџan in his efforts to destroy the last vestiges of democracy in Turkey. Nor was any mention made of the reality that decades of illegal immigration in the U.S. have resulted in a disastrous California illiteracy rate of 23% (33% in Los Angeles County). Instead, there is much "progressive" pabulum regarding the need to "empower full inclusion and social cohesion"; establish in migrants' destination countries "open and accessible information points" in "a language the migrant understands"; and, last but not least, a new category of "climate refugees."
"Full inclusion and social cohesion" evidently include mutual respect of all migrant cultures, without mentioning that some of these cultures include child marriage and female genital mutilation (FGM), or the fact that the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) officially endorses sharia law and discrimination against women and non-Muslims.
What the reader is also never told is that all migration to date is from poor third-world places to the well off Western countries with established welfare systems and that, with very few exceptions, the migrants are, at best, economic refugees who haven't been persecuted either politically or religiously. Moreover, the absorption capacity of these countries is finite before their welfare systems break down under the onslaught of the vast numbers of migrants this pact seemingly wants to encourage. Open borders and the welfare system are not compatible, Milton Friedman once said. Try as it might, the U.N. cannot change that.
Perhaps the greatest disservice the United Nations has done with this ill conceived "compact" is to purposefully erase the difference between legal and illegal immigration. This is no coincidence, despite protestations in the text that this agreement is "voluntary" and "non-binding" to U.N. members. Even a cursory reading of the 23 objectives listed in the compact make it clear beyond much doubt that the real goal of this mandate is to create a new "human right" to migration. By arguing that "refugees and migrants are entitled to the same universal human rights," the compact directly eliminates the crucial difference between refugees who flee persecution and are therefore entitled to political asylum and economic migrants. This essentially invalidates the noble Western principle of providing protection to those persecuted for their political or religious beliefs, which undergirds the Geneva Convention on Refugees.
Americans should be proud that President Trump was the first to make clear the disastrous consequences of this pact and pull the United States out. In the meantime, virtually all of Eastern Europe and many others have also pulled out. Thanks to Trump, when the leftist U.N. cabal assembles to celebrate its victory in Morocco next month, that victory will be pyrrhic at best.
Alex Alexiev is chairman of the Center for Balkan and Black Sea Studies (cbbss.org). He can be reached at alexievalex4@gmail.com.
FOLLOW US ON
Recent Articles
- The Truth About Trump’s Tariff Revisions … It’s All About 'The Art of the Deal'
- Remember, MAGA: This is No Time to Go Wobbly
- The Hill of Lies
- Trump’s Tariff Play: The Art of the Economic Reset
- Tax Cuts (and Tariffs) Need Not Be Paid For
- Tune Out the Media for What Matters
- Trump’s Tariffs Tackle Clinton’s China Carnage
- The Fruits of Trump’s Audacious Policies
- Will Trump’s Tariff Ambition Strangle MAGA in the Cradle?
- Navarro Tariffs are Too High
Blog Posts
- The Supreme Court affirms Justice Boasberg lacked jurisdiction over Trump’s deportation decision under the Alien Enemies Act
- DOGE spirit moves downstream -- to new U.S. Attorney who vows to probe the billions lost to L.A.'s homeless industrial complex
- A majority of self-identified leftists think political assassination is a societal good
- One Democrat has an idea for winning: a new ‘Contract with America’
- Kash Patel promotes an FBI agent who called J6 patriots and moms at school board meetings ‘terrorists’
- Tariffs threaten to put the nail in the ‘green’ energy coffin
- U.K. man fired for saying terrorists who murdered 1,200 Israelis are 'violent and disgusting'
- Abolish the Bar: The root of our corrupt and lawless judiciary
- Ignore Bill Ackman’s concerns; Trump’s economic plans are genius UPDATED
- A brief history of the stock market
- Top Colorado statehouse Democrat calls abortion good fiscal policy
- Wake up call for UK energy planners
- Protests for Dummies
- Maybe it's time to clean up the 25th
- Rage as a way of life