Arab 'towns' or 'camps'?
When Israeli military forces proactively engaged Arab terrorists in Judea and Samaria a few weeks ago, it was commonplace to read in the media, even Jewish-oriented media, references to “Arab refugee camps,” like “the Balata refugee camp.” That must have pleased Mr. Arafat.
Why not “the Arab town Balata” or “Balata, the Arab-populated suburb of Nablus”?
Balata is not a camp, with its implications of tents or huts; it has four-story buildings. Its population has lived there for decades, comprising Arabs who moved from one area of Palestine to another, migrating within the same land.
Many, if not most, of Balata Arabs’ ancestors would have immigrated to Eretz Israel in the first half of the 20th century, drawn by jobs created by enterprising Zionists. They came from neighboring Arab states across open land frontiers, while British Mandate police controlled Jewish aliyah through seaports.
Balata is near Joseph’s Tomb, a site holy to Jews that was desecrated by local Arabs at the beginning of the Oslo War in autumn 2000.
Journalists and others who use the term “refugee camp” in place of neutral terminology play into Arab propaganda. It is easily avoidable.
If one does use the Arab-oriented terminology, then for symmetry, why not call every town in Israel that is populated mostly of Jewish immigrants from Middle Eastern and North African states a “Jewish refugee camp,” alluding to Jews who fled or were forced from racist Arab or Moslem communities and states?
FOLLOW US ON
Recent Articles
- New York Greenlights Quarantine Camps
- Reality Check for Democrats
- A MAGA Siege of the Democrats’ Deep State
- Why Incel and 4B Culture Matter
- Defending Donald Trump: A Response to Jeffrey Goldberg and The Atlantic on the Signal Leak
- Are Judges Complicit in Lawfare?
- Deep Dive: The Signal Chat Leak
- Mark Steyn’s Reversal of Fortune
- Where We Need Musk’s Chainsaw the Most
- Trump Is Not Destroying the Constitution, but Restoring It
Blog Posts
- Nasty Venezuelan migrant who flashed taxpayer dollars and urged squatting, gets thrown out
- Watch white leftist women’s brains breaking—and repairing—in real-time
- In Pennsylvania, are Democrats stealing votes again?
- Knife control comes to the U.K.: Prime Minister Starmer bans Ninja swords
- This Tuesday, Wisconsonites must vote for Brad Schimel for the State Supreme Court
- Was Vietnam worth the cost?
- Democrats should get a clue from the Palestinians who are now marching against Hamas
- Trump takes on Fauxahontas's brainchild
- Consumer Sentiment Survey: This too shall pass
- If they only had knife control....
- Newsom and Walz struggle to appear normal
- Anti-Trump lawfare: yes, it's a conspiracy
- Criminal attack? You're on your own.
- Amid disaster, watch Bangkok clean up and rebuild
- Katherine Maher shoots herself, and NPR, in the foot