Obama's lock-step liberals on the Supreme Court
Perhaps we ought to start referring to Sonia Sotomayer and Elena Kagan as Judges Fiddle and Faddle, or perhaps Tweedledum and Tweedledee.
The newest members of the nation's highest court -- local Obama appointees Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan -- have agreed with each other in all 23 cases they've voted on, which is a supreme rarity, observers said.
Liberal critics who deride the Supreme Court's rightward shift over the past 10 years have cited conservative alliances like "Scalito," Justices Antonin Scalia and Samuel Alito.
But Scalia and Alito have agreed with each other in only 84 percent of cases in the current term, which winds up this month.
Legal scholars find the Sotomayor-Kagan mind meld a bit unusual but hardly shocking.
"The pattern of agreement is typically based on ideology or a view of the law," said professor Barry Friedman of NYU Law School. "It's not that surprising that Barack Obama's two appointees showed agreement."
But the New York twins don't just agree in general terms. Justices can agree fully or partially in a case, depending on whether they write a separate concurring or dissenting opinion. Often two justices will come to the same general conclusion for very different reasons.
Sotomayor, who joined the court two years ago, and Kagan, who began serving last October, agreed fully 91 percent of the time.

By contrast, the duo of Scalia and Alito agree fully only 59% of the time.
It's nice to have such independent thinkers sitting on the Supreme Court, isn't it? In truth, this points up how ridiculously easy it is to be a liberal. You don't really have to think very much at all. Liberals have a Pavlovian emotional response to just about everything so it's simply a matter of finding the right emotional hot button to get the proper result. "Social justice," "fairness," "for the children" usually does the trick. Liberals respond in universal ways to those code words and I suspect something similar is at work at the court.
FOLLOW US ON
Recent Articles
- Why Do Democrats Hate Women and Girls?
- There is No Politics Without an Enemy
- On the Importance of President Trump’s ‘Liberation Day’
- Let a Robot Do It
- I Am Woman
- Slaying the University Dragons
- Canada Embraces European Suicide
- A Multi-Point Attack on the National Debt
- Nearing the Final Battle Against the Deep State
- Now’s the Time to Buy a Nuke (Nuclear Power Plant, That Is)
Blog Posts
- So Milley was running the whole Ukraine war with Russia without telling the public -report
- New York’s ‘clean energy’ demands are unattainable, per industry’s own experts
- Astronauts carefully tell the truth
- California voters introduce new health care ‘access’ ballot initiative named after Luigi Mangione
- ‘American Oversight’? What a joke!
- Pete Hegseth in the line of fire—again
- Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney is accused of plagiarizing parts of his Oxford thesis
- France goes the Full Maduro, bans leading opposition frontrunner, Marine Le Pen, from running for the presidency
- Bob Lighthizer’s case for tariffs
- An eye for an eye, an order for order
- Peace on the Dnieper?
- Tesla protestor banner: 'Burn a Tesla, save democracy'
- Pro-abortionists amplify an aborton protest's impact
- A broken system waiting to crash
- The U.S. Navy on the border