PrintJune 7, 2010
Israel and the Crusaders?
New York Times columnist Ross Douthat draws a faulty parallel between the perils that doomed Christian Crusader rule in the Holy Land and Israel's challenges as a Jewish state in a hostile neighborhood ("Israel And Outremer" op-ed page, June 7).
Douthat's argument that Israel, like the Crusaders, is isolated in the world fails to take into account that, despite the sound and fury over the flotilla incident, Israel recently became a full-fledged member of the Organization for Economic Cooperation Development -- the premier international club of developed nations. Palestinian attempts to block its accession were resoundingly rejected.
Israel also has robust trade relations with Europe, India, China, and other major players. Its tourism industry attracts millions of visitors from all over the world. And despite some disagreements with the White House, it retains a wide range of political, economic and security ties with the United States. The Crusaders had no such advantages in the world of the 12th Century.
Douthat's further argument that Israel is an alien Crusader-like conqueror and a soon-to-be Jewish minority west of the Jordan River, also doesn't hold up to historical and demographic reality. Unlike the Crusaders, Jews have been an indigenous people in the Holy Land for thousands of years. Even after the Roman conquest, there remained a continuous Jewish presence there to this very day. Also, recent studies show that, with a rising Jewish birth rate and a declining Palestinian/Arab birth rate, the so-called demographic "time bomb" has lost much of its potency.
While the Crusaders were foreign implants, Israel today is firmly rooted in its ancient home. And the perils it faces, while very real, pale in comparison with graver threats to its existence that it confronted and overcame in the first 25 years of its existence -- Douthat's doomsday scenario to the contrary notwithstanding.
To comment on this or any other American Thinker article or blog, you must be a subscriber to our ad-free service. Login to your subscription to access the comments section. You can subscribe on a monthly basis for $6.79 a month or for a year at $69.99
Login
Subscribe / Change PwdAd Free / Commenting Login
FOLLOW US ON
Recent Articles
- The Danes and the Greenlanders: How They See Trump's America
- The USAID Case: Judge Amir Ali’s $2 Billion Defiance Escalates
- Terrifying Tariffs: Tax Policy as Back-Door Foreign Aid
- Dr. Marty Makary’s ‘Blind Spots’ Book Is At Odds With Established Findings
- Reforming the Kennedy Center
- Is ActBlue a Criminal Enterprise?
- America’s New Tough Love Foreign Policy
- Democrats Stand for Ukraine but Sit for America
- A Friend for Trump in Italy
- Trump’s Digital Fort Knox: Bitcoin, the Dollar, and America’s Financial Future
Blog Posts
- After blowing $9 billion on 'free' health care for illegals, California's Gov. Gavin Newsom asks for a bailout
- Trump throws down the gauntlet to the out-of-control federal district court judges *UPDATED*
- Ronald Reagan also had a slow economic start
- Getting the left out of the political wilderness
- Oregon selects a trans-turtle and a trans-meteor to sit on a ‘mental health advisory board’
- Fly the DEI skies...and hope that you land safely
- This 70-year-old woman is serving 9 years in prison
- Stacey Abrams really, really, wants 'her' $2 billion from Biden's EPA slush fund
- The (un)masked magician’s apprentice
- Schumer’s attempted shutdown will backfire bigly
- The Democrats are so passionate ...
- Biden and the U.S. Steel case
- Jay Bhattacharya's promise on vaccine safety
- MAGA moon over Greenland?
- Trump must designate the Muslim Brotherhood a terrorist organization