November 26, 2007
Poor and minorities hardest hit (updated)
The media narrative on the Cosco Busan oil spill into San Francisco Bay has largely focused on piteous waterfowl and incompetence on the part of the ship's crew, the Coast Guard, and the slow response of disaster relief efforts. But today, Jonathan Curiel of the San Francisco Chronicle gets down to business with the old stand-by of the media, the poor suffering disproportionately.
Two days after the Cosco Busan spilled 58,000 gallons of bunker fuel into San Francisco Bay, Khamnoi Vilaikam grabbed his fishing poles and drove to one of his favorite spots: a shoreline minutes away from his home in Richmond. [....]Only when Vilaikam returned home that Friday night, and he and a son had eaten some of the fish they had caught, did Vilaikam watch a TV newscast and realize the bay was polluted by oil that killed birds, shut down beaches and prompted state officials to consider a ban on bay fishing.Vilaikam, one of scores of subsistence fishers in the Bay Area, hasn't fished in the bay since."I got fish - striper bass," said Vilaikam. "The fish was OK. We come and eat. After that, they said it was an oil spill. After that, we didn't go."Subsistence fishers - low-income anglers often from immigrant communities - rely on their catches to feed themselves and their family. On a single outing, Vilaikam can take in more than 30 fish - enough to last him, his wife and their three children for a week.
It is terrible that the Bay was polluted anew, and I admire immigrants like Mr. Vilaikam who work multiple jobs, minimize expenses, and are self-reliant. But feeding your family all week long from fish caught in San Francisco Bay is a very bad idea. The Bay is polluted, Cosco Busan aside. There is heavy metal pollution and chemical pollution. Richmond is home to one of the biggest refineries on the West Coast, and careful though Chevron must be, I cannot help but believe that Richmond is a poor spot from which to take fish destined for the family dinner table.
So why doesn't the Chron article mention these well-known facts? Mr. Vilaikam and his family may in fact be better off staying away from Bay-caught fish.
Update: It appears that Mr. Vilaikam has been ignoring catch limits.
Update: It appears that Mr. Vilaikam has been ignoring catch limits.
In the Chronicle article, it states:
On a single outing, Vilaikam can take in more than 30 fish - enough to last him, his wife and their three children for a week.
A limit of 2 per day is described here on California Department Fish and Game website.
It seems that we are all better off now that he has stopped feeding his family polluted fish.
It seems that we are all better off now that he has stopped feeding his family polluted fish.
To comment on this or any other American Thinker article or blog, you must be a subscriber to our ad-free service. Login to your subscription to access the comments section. You can subscribe on a monthly basis for $6.79 a month or for a year at $69.99
Login
Subscribe / Change PwdAd Free / Commenting Login
FOLLOW US ON
Recent Articles
- Trump-O-Phobia Drives Some Americans to Questionable Greener Pastures Overseas
- A Businessman and a Brilliant Strategist
- A Remarkable Headline for a Fascinating Story
- Democrats Unmask Themselves
- How Mexico Became China’s Trojan Horse in U.S. Trade
- Covid Redux: The Bird Flu Scare
- A Taste of the Swamp
- Do We Have 677 Unelected Presidents?
- Global Relations beyond the Prime Directive
- The Democrat Party: The Enemy Within?
Blog Posts
- The CDC website really needs to update its COVID protocols
- Hands in your back pocket
- Birthright citizenship: The facts
- ‘She’s my little Musk coupe’
- The Biden White House mixed it up with not one but two autopens
- The Shakespeare National Trust determines that Shakespeare is ‘not to be’
- Carville tells Democrats to quit making asses of themselves
- About that Texas congressman who called the transgender member of Congress 'Mister' ...
- A federal district court judge erases Trump’s ability to rid the country of enemy aliens
- In the UK, rape gangs are OK, pictures of women sans hijabs not so much
- Bacha Bazi still being practiced in Afghanistan; young boys sexually abused
- UN judge convicted of forcing a woman into indentured servitude
- What are capital gains, really?
- Trump begins restoring law and order