What if Roe is reversed?
Nina Easton of the Boston Globe plays the "what if?" game on a possible Supreme Court overturning of Roe v. Wade. Unsurpsingly, whe swallows whole a number of pro—abortion shibboleths in proclaiming that the GOP cold face trouble in suburban Congressional races.
First, the Supreme Court is very unlikely to overturn Roe in a single decision. Much more likely would be a willingness of the Court to reign in some of the most dramatic extensions of the absolute right proclaimed by Roe. Most Americans favor reasonable limits on abortion, such as ending partial birth infanticide.
Second, if Roe were overturned, abortion would not be instantly outlawed, despite what the pro—abortion lobby would have you believe. Abortion would become a matter of state regulation once again. Only in the red states would it be likely for abortion to be outlawed. Blue states would continue to allow abortion as permissively as the legislatures care to permit.
Third, the House of representatives has nothing to do with confirming Supreme Court Justices. Exactly what would candidates supporting Roe say to win over voters and get them to reject Republican incumbents?
Ms. Easton lives and works in Washington. Her appearances on Brit Hume's show indicate that she doesn't drool and can form coherent sentences on the first try. I woud expect better from her.
Thomas Lifson 11 17 05
FOLLOW US ON
Recent Articles
- The Death of the Center-Left in America
- ‘Make Peace, You Fools! What Else Can You Do?’
- When Nuclear Regulation Goes Awry
- The Danger of Nothing
- A New Pope With Courage
- Not in Kansas Any More
- Democrats Dying on the Most Desolate Hills
- If She’s an Astronaut … I’m a Jet Fighter Pilot
- Is the Jihadist Trojan Horse Winning?
- Who Has the Best American Autobiography?
Blog Posts
- Celebrate Earth Day by not burning a Tesla
- Minnesota state bureaucrat charged with vandalizing Teslas to the tune of $20,000 is let off scot-free
- Trump’s plan for Gaza vs. the New York Times
- What’s next for Syria?
- Tulsi Gabbard's latest Biden revelation
- Mexican ammo wranglers
- Rep. Jamie 'Maryland Man' Raskin also threatens Trump supporters
- The eight narrative fallacies that drive American politics
- Summertime reality twisted into climate exasperation
- Life discovered on a distant planet?
- The answer is not blowing in the wind
- Letitia James: it's either/or
- Harvard elitism meets Donald Trump
- The GEC is finally more than mostly dead
- We're not the same