After witnessing the first detonation of the atomic bomb in New Mexico, J. Robert Oppenheimer, a brilliant Princeton University physicist who helped lead the Manhattan Project, remembered a line from the Bhagavad Gita and compared the explosion’s brilliance to a thousand suns.  He uttered these haunting words, “I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds.”  This deplorable writer has a similar sense when looking at the implosion of institutions and values in the USA.  This implosion is multi-layered, covering philosophical, theological, legal, and political institutions and values over a long period of time.

The most noteworthy philosophical change is the comfort level of political and non-political discourse with the philosopher Frederick Nietzsche’s “transvaluation of values.”  Under Nietzsche’s rubric, philosophy was tending away from overarching biblical values defining Western civilization in the direction of a complete renovation, whereby what had been considered good would be considered evil and vice-versa.  In Nietzsche’s masterwork, Thus Spake Zarathustra, Zarathustra is coming down a mountain and encounters a wise man and is surprised that this wise man does not know that “God is dead.”  What follows from this “death” is that morality, which derives from belief in God, is transformed and reversed.  Values are being transvalued as we look forward to a new type of humans, the übermenschen, who will exemplify the new value system.

This transformation of the moral landscape has been actively underway in the USA since the 19th century, notably in the philosophy of Ralph Waldo Emerson.  The philosophy building on the campus of Harvard University is named after Emerson, who was a professor there.  Emerson’s mystical transcendentalism was influenced by the idea of the Oversoul from Indian philosophy and would eventually influence the theosophists such as Madame Blavatsky and Annie Besant.

According to Emerson, the Oversoul is the source of all truth and wisdom, and it is through our connection to it that we can achieve spiritual growth and enlightenment.  It can be accessed through meditation, and it is also the realm through which souls travel after death, looking forward to successive reincarnations. 

In addition, Emerson was influenced by the English romantic poets, who tended to deify nature.  A psychoanalyst who supervised me when I was a counseling intern at a Canadian mental hospital fifty years ago said to me that our human lives mirror the seasons of nature — spring, summer, fall, and winter.  We burst into life (spring), flourish for a time (summer), begin to decline (fall), and move lastly to our stages of collapse and death (winter).

Although I was an atheist at the time of my internship, surprisingly and with no previous use of the word “salvation,” I asked him, “What about salvation?  Where does that come into your metaphor?”

Without hesitation, the good doctor said to me, “Salvation?  There is no such thing as salvation.”

I replied, “But there must be salvation!  We not only mirror nature, but there is an important sense in which we transcend nature!”  He was so annoyed by my insistence that he stood up and walked out of his office, leaving me sitting in my chair alone in front of his desk.

In 1859, Charles Darwin’s On the Origin of Species was published.  Only eleven years earlier, Karl Marx and Fredrich Engels had co-authored and published the Communist Manifesto, which would be followed later in the 19th century by Marx’s Das Kapital.  Marx’s ideations were preceded and to some degree grounded in the speculations of Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel, who in 1807 had challenged most of the assumptions about the mind and the universe that inhered in Lutheran theology.

Although Marx’s “dialectic materialism” was different in some important ways from Hegel’s dialectic, both moved away from a linear conception of life and away from the mystery concept of Divine Providence to explain historical or natural events.  Darwin’s volume challenged the biblical account of creation and replaced it with a naturalistic explanation — evolution — to account for the species occupying planet Earth and for our human identity as Homo sapiens.  For Marx and Engels, the ideas of capital, work, individual motivation, wealth creation, productivity, and leadership were all the products of a selfish individualism that was tied in with a self-serving mythology about God and morality.

In an important paper published in 2006, the author, building on the published Ph.D. dissertation of the illustrious professor Morton White, sees a strong link between John Dewey, America’s leading philosopher of education, and Hegelian philosophy, which, as noted above, breaks from Christianity (particularly Lutheranism) in various crucial ways.  Further, although Dewey does not declare himself a Marxist, his affinity with Marxist ideology has been noted.  One commentator wrote in this regard, “Like Marx, Dewey has a social interpretation of human nature [my italics].  He thinks that the doctrine of ‘individualism,’ as traditionally understood, creates a false image of ‘a residual individual who is not a member of any association at all.’”

The above individuals have been crucial in undermining the moral and intellectual roots of civilization.  Their subversion took place in the 19th century, with only John Dewey writing his obscure but ultimately destructive ideas into the 20th century.  All this happened before two world wars, before Hitler and Mussolini, before the New Deal, before Russia became the USSR, before China became a “People’s Republic,” before the Sexual Revolution, before the banning of prayers in public schools, before the searing of conscience leading to large-scale abortions, before the erotic lullabies of the Beatles, before Mr., Miss, and Mrs. became pejorative designations for too many people, and before the shift of the Democrats to communism in the 21st century.

Image: Pashi via Pixabay, Pixabay License.