Free college won't solve the student debt crisis
Student debt tops $1.2 trillion. With all the consequences of mounting student loan debt taken into account, liberal policymakers have generally proposed one of two solutions: heavily subsidizing student loans or forgiving outstanding student loan debt. There’s a more radical third “solution”: having the government foot the bill for all tuition. The third option may be too radical even for the American left, though it’s currently championed by Bernie Sanders. Sanders would like to follow the Scandinavian model in making higher education free of charge to all students.
Regardless of what you think of the government involving itself more in higher education than it already does, some might assume that this would at least take care of the student debt problem. They would be wrong.
Above is charted average student loan debt in Sweden (where tuition is free) versus the United States. And while there is obviously a greater amount of student loan debt in the U.S., most would certainly expect a much larger gap when we’re comparing ourselves to a nation where college is free. In fact, average student loan debt in Sweden in 2013 was the equivalent of $19,000 USD, vs. $24,000 in the U.S.
Students graduating in Germany (before they socialized tuition) and the U.K. actually have lower student loan debt than students in Sweden. Not only that, but 85% of Swedish students graduate with debt, while only 50% of American students do. The reason may have something to do with the fact that student loan debt centers more on costs of living while away at college – rent, food, etc. – than with actual tuition itself.
Not only would “free” tuition likely fail to alleviate the problem of student loan debt, but it has its own set of consequences. In Denmark, another country that offers college free of charge, students are much more likely to pursue the so-called “luxury” degrees over those in STEM fields. Far from encourage more students to attend college and build human capital, free tuition in the U.S. would likely have the same effect that it has had in Denmark in encouraging students to pursue what they find interesting rather than what will turn into a career.
Matt Palumbo is the author of The Conscience of a Young Conservative and In Defense of Classical Liberalism.
Ad Free / Commenting Login
FOLLOW US ON
Recent Articles
- Trump’s Chess Game Is Improving
- Trump Has the Taxpayers’ Back
- Downsizing the Federal Government
- Is There A Problem With Colorado State University And Its Nipah Virus Research?
- Media Titans Rattled by Lawsuits
- Tribalism: The Key to Understanding Islam
- Reaching for the Source of Meaning and Certitude
- The Musk-eteers Reveal You’ve Been Living in a Simulated Reality
- America Must, Can, And Should Renew Its Nuclear Energy Dominance
- Trump and the States Confront Digital Issues
Blog Posts
- Democrats decry Trump’s cancellation of ‘green’ subsidies because he’s ending a ‘low-cost’ industry
- Larry Summers and four other Democrat Treasury secretaries come out together to howl about DOGE
- Anti-white propagandists spread disinformation to spur race wars in South Africa
- Democrats are politically bipolar on illegal immigration
- Country as home
- Legos called ‘heteronormative,’ problematic
- President Trump addresses his largest TV audience ever during an interview before the Super Bowl yesterday
- Lawfare 2.0: A New York judge launches a coup
- Politically bipolar
- My experience with USAID and Israel
- Marco Rubio, not Obama, on Cuba
- Homeland Security Secretary Noem accuses FBI of leaking news of ICE raids to the press
- Rathergate at 21
- Revisiting Benghazi
- The Second Amendment: new Trumpian opportunities