Baucus bill offers some magical cost savings
Cato's Michael Cannon, writing in the New York Post , has uncovered some nifty budget gimmicks being used by Finance chairman Max Baucus as he tries to sell his bill.
Houdini would be proud of this guy. And the lesson Cannon is trying to teach is always watch what the magician is doing with his left hand because he's using his right to misdirect you:
The Senate Finance Committee will perpetrate a huge fraud on the US public today. Chairman Max Baucus promises to hold a final vote on his health-care overhaul -- most of whose costs he has hidden with budgetary gimmicks.The widely reported numbers are wrong: This bill would increase the deficit and cost more than $2 trillion over 10 years.
Yes, the headlines on the Congressional Budget Office's preliminary cost estimate were that the bill could cost $829 billion over 10 years and trim the federal deficit by $81 billion. But those numbers are pure fantasy -- as CBO plainly, if gently, indicated.
First off, Baucus relies on some cuts that we know won't actually get made.
Long ago, Congress enacted a series of annual cuts to Medicare physician payments that were supposed to begin in 2003. Starting that very year, however, Congress has repeatedly blocked those cuts.
Yet Baucus -- contrary to all experience -- assumes Congress will let those cuts take place starting in 2012. That implausible assumption creates some $234 billion in "savings" that will never materialize. Factor them out, and the supposed $81 billion in deficit reduction becomes $153 billion in fresh deficit spending.
The CBO's language pooh-poohing Baucus on this was pure bureaucratese -- but the agency essentially told Baucus: If the sun rises in the west from 2012 through 2019, then yes, this bill would reduce the deficit.
That's not all. What the Baucus bill does is pass a lot of costs on to the private sector - which, of course, will eventually be passed on to consumers. How large a cost?
The Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation found that new federal and state spending accounts for just 40 percent of the Bay State's reforms' cost -- and the private-sector mandates for 60 percent. Apply that ratio to the Baucus bill, and its actual cost exceeds $2 trillion.Let me add one thing that is not being bandied about much in talk about how much any of these bills will cost.
The subsidies the federal government will pay to people in order for them to afford health insurance are going to go up - fast. That's been the experience at state level after enacting mandated insurance coverage. And since the subsidies will be going to even the modestly wealthy (top rate for families will be an income level of $82,000), no one can predict how much more those subsidies are going to cost the taxpayer. Chances are good it will be substantially more than they are figuring.
We are headed for a trainwreck - even though we can see what's coming from miles ahead.
Hat Tip: Ed Lasky
Ad Free / Commenting Login
FOLLOW US ON
Recent Articles
- Will the MAGA Barbarian Invasion Succeed?
- A ‘Putin’s Puppet’ President? Obama’s Truly Shocking Record
- Faith, Hope, and Babies
- Did COVID Nearly Start a Revolution?
- China’s 4-Stage Strategy to Surpass the USA
- America and Israel Share The Same Enemy
- The Folly in Aggressive NATO Expansion in the Post-Soviet Era
- Chronicle of a Mugging
- Everything You Know About the USAID Case May be Wrong
- Sanctuary City Mayors Deny Harboring Criminal Aliens
Blog Posts
- After a campaign of soft and silky ads, Ontario goes the Full Putin on electricity tariffs, vowing to shut the electricity off in three states
- Butcher Christians in the Middle East and receive a VIP invite to an EU conference in Brussels
- Oregon’s governor establishes an ‘abortion provider appreciation day’
- Why a former Columbia professor is glad that the feds have yanked $400 million in funding from it
- China is an existential threat to this country
- A Hamas supporter who graduated from Columbia got his green card revoked, and the left is losing its mind
- A history lesson, using Ronald Reagan
- The Biden autopen scandal could be a path to cleaning up some judicial corruption
- Syria: The graveyard of Christianity
- What went wrong with the Democrats?
- Canada, Europe bemoan the very tariffs they levy, advantages they give their own industries
- A deplorable explains why the Dems will probably run AOC in 2028
- In Paterson, New Jersey, the local Muslims show their hand
- A fair offer faux women will refuse
- With autopen in hand